Username Remember Me?
Password   forgot password?
   
1 of 3
1
Spring Subway - Zhang Yibai
Onderhond
Posted: 08 June 2009 05:36 AM   [Ignore]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  389

Joined  2007-07-25

Zhang Yibai is possibly one of the most overlooked directors of the Chinese film industry. Spring Subway is his first film and already has all his talents on display. It’s also a perfect film for gaining international attention, still almost nobody seems to know about Yibai’s work. I’ve wrote about Lost Indulgence, Yibai’s latest film, before but even that film seems to have slipped by most people. All the more reason to write about this neat little gem.

Spring Subway is a film floating in between the realms of arthouse and mainstream cinema. It’s also nested somewhere between Chinese and HK cinema, so maybe it’s this duality that’s keeping the film from finding its target audience. At the core of the film lies a dramatic love story about a couple coming to Beijing. Seven years have passed and even though they are still very much in love with each other, small incidents are slowly driving them apart.

The titular “Spring” seems to refer to the lighter and fresher atmosphere found in the film. It’s not your typical Chinese poor man’s social drama, but more grounded in a modern/urban Chinese society. When the couple is introduced they come off as a gentle, somewhat quirky combination of two lovable people. Yibai seems to be constructing a setup for a lightweight romantic drama, and during the first 20-30 minutes lures the audience in using this hook.

Slowly though, the relationship between the two changes. Lies enter their relationship, and even though they are always just inches away from clearing the skies between them, small and insignificant details prevent them from leveling with each other. Small things grow bigger and slowly the gap becomes hard to bridge. These key moments are often shown through daydream-like sequences or voice-overs, underlining the difference between what is being said, what is thought and how that affects their relationship.

Visually Yibai has nothing more to prove. He applies a more modern look than most of his peers, but the use of color is still typically Chinese. Sometimes even a little reminiscent of Wong Kar-Wai’s work, with lots of greens and reds composing the bulk of the color palette. Still, it is quite refreshing to see them used in a more modern/urban setting. The camera work itself is impeccable, stylish and almost dreamy. The score is equally nice, with traditional Chinese sounds and instruments mixed in with a more contemporary sound, yet still in line with the romantic atmosphere of the film. It’s not a score that begs for attention, but it surfaces at just the right times in just the right places.

Considering the titular Spring, the light tone of the beginning and the happy couple setup, the way Yibai forces the couple apart is surprisingly painful. The first half hour makes sure you feel for these people, but each failed attempt to get back closer together becomes more and more bitter, to the point where you’re starting to wonder where Yibai is going with all of this. Luckily the ending didn’t feel out of place and suited the film. No cop out at all, but the only ending this film deserved.

Spring Subway is a film that starts off pretty jolly and cute, yet delivers some small but bitter punches throughout its running time. Yibai does a magnificent job at both romantic and dramatic angles and delivers a beautifully shot and scored film, revolving around a lovable couple. There are some tiny side stories also able to touch in all their reduced simplicity, added to reinforce the theme of the film. They aren’t really necessary additions as the core story is strong enough, but they do provide some welcome relief from time to time.

The inability to communicate has always been one of my favored dramatic themes, one often found in Asian dramas. Spring Subway answers to that description, although the execution of the film is more frivolous and less minimalistic than usually the case. It’s interesting to see the little details that make people grow apart, wrapped within a film that’s entertaining and simply magnificent to look at. Highly recommended. 4.5*/5.0*

Original Review

Signature

My collected thoughts on interesting films, music and games:
http://www.onderhond.com/blog/personal

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 09 June 2009 10:48 AM   [Ignore]   [#1]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

Couldn’t agree more on this film, though I haven’t watched Lost, Indulgence and Curiosity Killed The Cat was pretty disappointing. Regardless, Spring Subway is a cracking debut and far more… lively, sensual, playful, than most arthouse Chinese cinema ever manages.

His section for About Love is not bad, if not the best of the three. I should stick a review of that up… certainly didn’t get enough attention.

Profile
 
 
Onderhond
Posted: 10 June 2009 04:30 AM   [Ignore]   [#2]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  389

Joined  2007-07-25

Hmmm, really like Curiosity Killed the Cat, it’s not the best film out there, but it felt very unique, even more so coming from a Chinese director. And if I’m right, I liked Yibai’s part in About Love the best.

(and hi to you Eight Rooks! Long time no see smile )

Signature

My collected thoughts on interesting films, music and games:
http://www.onderhond.com/blog/personal

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 10 June 2009 09:11 AM   [Ignore]   [#3]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

Long time indeed, Onderhond. I was still posting when you first came along here, I think, but I remember you from the Production IG channel too.

I didn’t hate Curiosity, but it just didn’t feel like Yibai had much of a handle on what he wanted to do with the genre. Not unlike Zhang Bingjian’s Suffocation in that respect, another film where it’s obviously aping Western tropes to some degree - “the first Chinese psycho movie!” - but you can see the constraints of working under SARFT’s beady eye holding the production back. Spring Subway was a lot less weighed down, as if he’d found a story he could safely tell without annoying any government officials and was free to just go for it.

Profile
 
 
Onderhond
Posted: 10 June 2009 09:16 AM   [Ignore]   [#4]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  389

Joined  2007-07-25

Maybe it’s because I’m not too familiar with the weight of SARFT, but Zhixi is probably my fav Chinese film. Awesome art direction in that film, and storywise more than satisfying.

Signature

My collected thoughts on interesting films, music and games:
http://www.onderhond.com/blog/personal

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 10 June 2009 09:25 AM   [Ignore]   [#5]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

Huh. Well, damn. I’d never pick it as a best of anything… although I can see why someone would like it. It does have some fantastic imagery, Ge You can basically sleepwalk through anything and still act people off the screen, and I could see a staggering film under there… but I just remember thinking it really, really felt that it was setting up the ending more to please the censors than anything else. I do own the DVD, though admittedly it’s a long time since I watched it.

Still, if we’re talking mainland, it doesn’t hold a candle to In The Heat Of The Sun for me. Favourite Chinese film and one of the greatest ever made, IMO.

Profile
 
 
Onderhond
Posted: 10 June 2009 10:02 AM   [Ignore]   [#6]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  389

Joined  2007-07-25

really felt that it was setting up the ending more to please the censors than anything else.

Hmmm, maybe with the strict censorship in mind that the ending came off that way, it never really crossed my mind, and I found the ending fitting for the film. But like you said already, it’s mostly the superb imagery (those fishies!) and the amazing sound design that pulled me in.

Close competitor for me is Baober in Love. Never heard of The Heat of the Sun, but based on some screenies it will have a hard time competing with earlier mentioned films smile

Signature

My collected thoughts on interesting films, music and games:
http://www.onderhond.com/blog/personal

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 10 June 2009 10:11 AM   [Ignore]   [#7]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

I do remember you’re all about the moving pictures, yes. wink In The Heat of the Sun is still a visually attractive film, but there are no FX I remember and nothing… artistic?

Again, I liked Baober, own the DVD, but I thought the ending was… not great. I didn’t think what I could make out of the plot development (with the aid of ghastly machine translated subs) warranted it. I’ve only seen two of Li Shaohong’s films - (I have The Door, but it’s not really watchable without subs) and Baober doesn’t come close to Stolen Life for me.

You hit me with dazzling imagery, I throw actorly productions back at you… plus ca change, I guess.  cheese

Profile
 
 
Onderhond
Posted: 10 June 2009 10:25 AM   [Ignore]   [#8]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  389

Joined  2007-07-25

Still need to see Stolen Life (and I have The Door too, no subs indeed. Free DVD at YesAsia, no?). And it’s not so much about FX as it is about artistic merit (though very personal I know).

And just for the record, throwing Lu Cha at you. wink

Signature

My collected thoughts on interesting films, music and games:
http://www.onderhond.com/blog/personal

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 10 June 2009 10:31 AM   [Ignore]   [#9]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

Come on, now. Slick Chinese arthouse featuring one of the most beautiful women on the face of the earth? Way ahead of you.

I still need to watch Wo Ai Ni, come to that.

I wonder what you’d make of Mirth/Where Have All The Flowers Gone, now I think of it. I thought it was a terrible film, but the artistry is quite something. I’m fairly confident you’d see something in there that’d interest you, if you haven’t caught it already.

Profile
 
 
Ard Vijn
Posted: 10 June 2009 10:46 AM   [Ignore]   [#10]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  4530

Joined  2007-06-03

This is like watching a game of tennis!
I’m not sure who is winning, but it’s nice to know that I’m not the only one appreciative of Wei Zhao’s beauty. cheese
 
Easy on the titles, guys, I’m googling like mad to keep up…

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 10 June 2009 11:00 AM   [Ignore]   [#11]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

Oh, I could carry on like this all day… well, no, I’d run out some time, plus even if I’m out of a job I still have other things to do.

Fun though.

Still, Vicki Zhao? I’ll throw A Time For Love at you, Ard, I guess. Romeo & Juliet knockoff (of sorts) stuck out on Valentine’s Day in mainland China a few years back - while it’s obvious multiplex fodder it’s still pretty well acted and shot and extraordinarily bittersweet for a mainstream release starring a woman who’s still a pinup, for all her acting prowess. The ending in particular had me thinking “what the fudge?” - and no, when I say Romeo & Juliet I don’t mean quite like that. wink

I have the sudden urge to watch Painted Skin again now. God, I’m weak…

Profile
 
 
Onderhond
Posted: 10 June 2009 11:21 AM   [Ignore]   [#12]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  389

Joined  2007-07-25

Oh yeah, Where Have All The Flowers Gone, that’s a good film alright! (so was Rainbow). Wo Ai Ni on the other hand was slightly disappointing.

So maybe I could interest you in some Zu Zhou (Curse Of Lola) Eight? wink

Signature

My collected thoughts on interesting films, music and games:
http://www.onderhond.com/blog/personal

Profile
 
 
Ard Vijn
Posted: 10 June 2009 11:31 AM   [Ignore]   [#13]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  4530

Joined  2007-06-03

Eight Rooks - June 10, 2009, 11:00am

Still, Vicki Zhao?

 
Yes, Vicky Zhao.
Huh?
Who did YOU mean when you referred to Lu Cha as being “Slick Chinese arthouse featuring one of the most beautiful women on the face of the earth”?

Profile
 
 
Eight Rooks
Posted: 10 June 2009 11:38 AM   [Ignore]   [#14]
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  292

Joined  2009-04-14

Ah. My phrasing is throwing you off, Ard. Try “So, another Vicki Zhao fan?” Apologies. wink

Profile
 
 
Ard Vijn
Posted: 10 June 2009 11:46 AM   [Ignore]   [#15]
Avatar
RankRankRankRank

Administrator

Total Posts:  4530

Joined  2007-06-03

Accepted. cheese
Here is a peace offering:

zhaowei.jpg

Profile
 
 
   
1 of 3
1